Edinburgh Cinema

Edinburgh’s cinemas have their own, different feel. When I visit them, I’ll be writing about both the film and the place, giving you the organic experience. Film critics on the big scale can’t really cater for this, so I hope my reviews bring something extra in this respect.

A Fantastic Woman

download

It's the most talked about trans movie since the problematic The Danish Girl (2016), but A Fantastic Woman already has superior foundations through its casting and plot. Unlike Eddie Redmayne's depiction of Lili Elbe, the predicament of trans actress Daniela Vega's three-dimensional Marina does not involve a reason or fateful spark to explain why she is trans: she simply is. Instead, at the heart of the narrative is the reaction of institutions and individuals to a situation, when Marina's 57-year-old partner dies. From this, we see what a 21st century society thinks of a transgender woman. Marina is suspected by police officers of complicity in the partner's death, and reviled by the almost-in-laws for what they see as her perversion and chimera appearance.

What follows at the personal level is Marina's path through the trauma of loss, sometimes via Kafkaesque interrogation, other times dreamscape or hard realities. Literally and figuratively, the endgame coincides with her finding her voice.

Yet because of this narrative of suffering and silence and defiance, it can be argued that A Fantastic Woman is no masterpiece. Marina is decent, sincere and misunderstood, while those who oppose her are always objectionable. Marina is worthy of sympathy, but her arc by the end of the film feels complete and we can all go home. My own range of emotions, concurrently, rarely extended beyond anger and concern, though one hallucinating dance scene felt wonderfully free: a shift from documentary and drama into art.

Nevertheless, as a credible, believable representation of trans, let me count some ways in which this film is an upgrade on the misjudged schmaltz of The Danish Girl. What was once the taboo subject of sex in the life of a trans woman is abandoned for Marina's sensuous relationship with her partner: they kiss, they slow-dance, they fuck. I loved her anger, her 'You want me to act like an animal?' as she stamps all over the 4x4 car of the hateful ex-wife of her partner. Finally, Marina has a life of her own, as waitress and singer, no simpering caricature this, like The Danish Girl's retreat into play-school domesticity. Marina both endures and grows stronger as an independent adult in an adult's world, and given past and even present representations of trans as broken mirror, this is a portrayal to celebrate. 

Red Sparrow
The Square
 

Comments

No comments made yet. Be the first to submit a comment
Guest
Friday, 21 September 2018

Captcha Image

What's On This Week

My Latest Posts

BlacKkKlansman
September 16, 2018

BlacKkKlansman

September 16, 2018

BlacKkKlansman

  BlacKkKlansman In an age of the absence of subtlety, BlacKkKlansman is arguably the perfect movie to tackle the issue of racism in America. It presents a black-and-white world of good versus evil, of racism and its opposite, in a clear-cut binary relationship. The cops – with one clear exception – are reasonable, anti-racist people, while th...
The Other Slavery
September 09, 2018

The Other Slavery

in Books

September 09, 2018

The Other Slavery

in Books

The Other Slavery by Andres Resendez My first feelings about the Native or First Nation Americans come in waves of visualizations. The names different tribes gave to the months: Geese Flying Moon; Strawberry Moon. They conjure up colours and movements come alive upon infinite midnight plains. The cruelty of European settlers intervenes. My reading ...
Fragments
September 02, 2018

Fragments

September 02, 2018

Fragments

  Fragments Yesterday evening I completed my move across town from one apartment to another. The experience was, and continues to be, disorientating. I guess everyone needs a place to call home. I start from scratch, again. I woke up from an anxiety nightmare early this morning. Soon after, was lying on the floor doing stre...
August 31, 2018

Forbidden Androgynies

Forbidden Androgynies Growing up in the 1980s, I remember particular cartoons that seemed indispensable and which even today seem impressively cool in their inventiveness. In no particular order, these include the disturbingly Satanic Thundercats with female icon Cheetara , as well as the more gently uplifting Dungeons and Dragons – with the wonder...
August 24, 2018

Algorithms of Oppression by Safiya Umoja Noble

in Books

  Algorithms of Oppression: How Search Engines Reinforce Racism by Safiya Umoja Noble Should the Internet be regulated? It's a question I've never thought about, until recently, and the reading of this book. Here is my review of a book about a topic I can barely talk about without looking like those aged politicians trying to grill Mark Zucker...
August 23, 2018

Sod's Law (Edinburgh Festival)

Sod's Law (Edinburgh Festival) A posh young aristo, singing lectures about fisting and 'man twats,' Sod's Law is a rather wonderful exploration of the history of homosexuality from the time of Henry VIII to the 21 st century. From the court of the English Tudor monarch through Molly Houses and Oscar Wilde, we get observations on various legislation...
August 22, 2018

Trans Pennine

Trans Pennine (Edinburgh Festival) A gentle, generally light, small-scale drama, Trans Pennine explores family life after the death of the wife/mother, and a suppressed secret that finally comes out. Of the three-person cast, an embittered husband/father is required to confront a past he'd rather not remember, with the aid of his grown-up son and d...
August 20, 2018

Gruff Rhys: Resist Phony Encores

Gruff Rhys: Resist Phony Encores Haunting, disarming, his voice trembling then strong and soothing. Gruff Rhys played and talked for an hour, songs sometimes in Welsh, sometimes English, occasionally mixing recorded sounds, adding voice over voice or gentle squeaking bird calls from a tiny machine. This performance was a rare and intimate plea...
August 19, 2018

Pussy Riot + The Estrons (Edinburgh Festival)

Pussy Riot + The Estrons (Edinburgh Festival) You say 'punk,' I think of skinny men with psycho eyes, about to launch themselves at you with Doc Marten feet and broken beer bottles. Punk as frustrated patriarchy, turned in on itself, lashing out at anyone who comes near. I'm so glad, then, that I went to watch the mesmerizing Pussy Riot last n...