Edinburgh Cinema

Edinburgh’s cinemas have their own, different feel. When I visit them, I’ll be writing about both the film and the place, giving you the organic experience. Film critics on the big scale can’t really cater for this, so I hope my reviews bring something extra in this respect.

Bad Education by Pedro Almodovar

BeFunky-Collage-Bad-Education

Bad Education by Pedro Almodovar

Mention director Pedro Almodovar and it's hard not to think of depictions of women and the LGBT community that are sensitive, sympathetic, and ultimately uplifting. All these virtues are captured in Almodovar's most famous work, All About My Mother (1999), with its representation of two trans female prostitutes. Agrado, whose speech at a theatre has become famous in its own right, is one of cinema's most charismatic trans characters, my only regret that it was played by cis-gendered Antonia San Juan. The other character, Lola, is played by the more convincingly androgynous Tony Canto, but gets little screen time, and is presented as a manipulative character who with little regard has given someone AIDS.

Almodovar has toyed with trans narratives since then, in his Gothic thriller The Skin I Live In (2011). This was a film that used trans as a trope for castration and is a far harder movie to like: in the story, a father gets his revenge on his daughter's rapist by performing gender reassignment surgery upon the rapist. What follows is a film of dubious gender politics and fantasy-like reassignment where the mad-professor-like father falls in love with his creation, and the creation herself reciprocates, at least until the end.

With mixed feelings from The Skin I Live In, I avoided further films by Almodovar. But I knew about Bad Education (2004), and last night I finally watched it.

It confirms to me how Almodovar is fascinated by, and finds beauty in, the young male, as well as (cis-gendered) women in general. At the heart of Bad Education is one of mainstream cinema's most beautiful actors, Gael Garcia Bernal, flitting through timelines in a tale of Catholic priests, abuse and extortion. In the story-within-a-story, Bernal becomes a voluptuous transgender female, a character to root for as she plots her revenge against the abusive priest of her childhood. Later, Bernal returns to the original narrative as an Adonis-like boy of fluid sexuality. At one point we see him swimming at the villa of a former friend, the ripples of the sun-lit pool a frame for his lithe movement underwater. Elsewhere in the story of many narrative shifts, we see what we think is Bernal's character as a small boy among many young boys swimming in an idyllic, sun-drenched lake.

The twist comes much later when we learn that Bernal is not the small boy but his brother. The small boy, we discover, grew up to be a leering, heroin-addicted trans woman, with a pronounced five o'clock shadow, a hooked nose and crooked mouth, and breast implants she crudely wants people to admire. To feed her heroin addiction, she both blackmails the priest and regularly takes money from her mother and grandmother. Like any crone or witch, she gets her comeuppance.

I use the word crone because it's the only character type that matches this trans character, and it is worth considering in relation to the other films of Almodovar. Bad Education is a sublime celebration of homoeroticism, and when Bernal does drag, he is magnetic. More so, by far, than the real trans character, a kind of monster that no one could root for.

I think back to the other representations of trans that Almodovar goes for: only when a cis-gendered female plays the part does Almodovar approach trans as something attractive. Bad Education, like the other Almodovar's films I've seen, are otherwise to be avoided if you're looking for a sympathetic depiction of trans, and that unfortunately for me is the much bigger twist than the one Almodovar intended for Bad Education.
Walk With Me
The Post
 

Comments

No comments made yet. Be the first to submit a comment
Guest
Thursday, 22 February 2018

Captcha Image

What's On This Week

February 09, 2018

What's On?

My Latest Posts

February 18, 2018

Black Panther

Black Panther If Superman were black, would the narrative be different? Like President Obama trying to get things done against a hostile senate, would Superman face resistance and conspiracy theories from Donald Trump, if he were from an inner-city African-American community? Would he still be seen as protector of the people, or threat? These were ...
February 17, 2018

The Shape of Water

The Shape of Water The protagonist doesn't speak, and neither does the one she loves. Her confidante is a single man in late middle age, struggling in vain for work. These are not the heroes you expect, the violence that punctuates the film isn't there to make you swoon in awe. The Shape of Water isn't a movie whose like you will have seen before, ...
February 11, 2018

A Shop I Used To Know

A Shop I Used To Know When you're six foot tall and trans-female, entering a women's clothes shop isn't like entering a cinema or a newsagent's. In M&S, the women seem so small – maybe it's the age of the average customer there? – that you can't help but stand out by comparison, even though it's got easier than it used to, from an emotional poi...
Walk With Me
February 10, 2018

Walk With Me

February 10, 2018

Walk With Me

Walk With Me It was during this film that I came up with the term chomper to describe the way such entertainments make me feel. Some forty minutes into this documentary (or was it thirty minutes, or twenty, or ten?), I felt myself become drowsy. Silently, and yet in a feverish desperation, I sought out the chewing gum in my bag that would help...
February 04, 2018

At the Dentist's

At the Dentist's The dentist's chair is a place of tension for me. In childhood I never cared about my teeth and saw dentists as my nemesis. Then one day in early adolescence I fell as I was getting off my school bus and smashed a front tooth. It got fixed but I'm permanently insecure about breaking it once more. Then last summer, after nearly...
February 03, 2018

Bad Education by Pedro Almodovar

Bad Education by Pedro Almodovar Mention director Pedro Almodovar and it's hard not to think of depictions of women and the LGBT community that are sensitive, sympathetic, and ultimately uplifting. All these virtues are captured in Almodovar's most famous work, All About My Mother (1999), with its representation of two trans female prostitutes. Agr...
The Post
January 28, 2018

The Post

January 28, 2018

The Post

The Post A shady US President trying to undermine the media, is all you need to know about this film to see it hits the zeitgeist. Like the Oscar-winning Spotlight (2016), it's a tale of newsrooms and investigative reporting serving as a crucial pillar of democracy. Like Spotlight too, it's a heavyweight ensemble, Spielberg behind the len...
January 27, 2018

George Monbiot: How Did We Get Into This Mess?

in Books

George Monbiot: How Did We Get Into This Mess? The raison d'etre of this collection of essays comes in the final chapter in a book looking for answers as to the state of the world today: In the United States, blue-collar workers angrily demand that they be left without health care, and insist that millionaires should pay less tax . . . What has hap...
January 21, 2018

In tribute to Laura Jane Grace

In tribute to Laura Jane Grace Back then, circa 2008, it's Tom Gabel singing to an acoustic set with their band. The song, called The Ocean , twists and turns melodically, the voice is straining passionately. The song is fucking good already, If I could have chosen where God would hide his heaven I'd wish for it to be the salt and swell of the ocea...