Edinburgh Cinema

Edinburgh’s cinemas have their own, different feel. When I visit them, I’ll be writing about both the film and the place, giving you the organic experience. Film critics on the big scale can’t really cater for this, so I hope my reviews bring something extra in this respect.

Star Wars: The Last Jedi

the-last-jedi-theatrical-I

Star Wars: The Last Jedi 15.12.17

I would watch this film again. Not for the lightsaber fights, which were strangely banal, or for the romance that develops between Boyega's Finn and Tan's Rose, which glowed slightly at the end. In fact not for the many shoulder-shrug participants of this movie: Oscar Isaac's ace pilot Po and his one-dimensional charisma; Laura Derne's heroic but stiffly boring turn as a rebel leader. I could go on, but what's the point? I wish this film had scaled down on the casting and accommodating sub-plots. It already has three outstanding performers: Luke Skywalker (Hamill), Rei (Ridley) and Kylo Ren (Driver). I understand that every actor in Hollywood wants to be in Star Wars, but sometimes, less is more.

Speaking of which, Mark Hamill's hermit-like Luke is simply divine. He broods on his island as a failed teacher, dry humour mixing with anger and bitterness, but his uplifting humanity is never in question. His dialogue with Yoda I particularly loved; Yoda who for the first time since Empire Strikes Back, comes across as loveable and benign. Beyond the rugged islands, Luke convinces too in his agile fight against Driver's Ren, with shades of The Matrix, leaving Ren to look lumbering and awkward. Luke, in short, is kick-ass in this movie as warrior, teacher and sexagenarian whose regrets are not nearly as bad as he thinks. Hyperbole perhaps, but his is the most wonderful sixty-something character I've seen on screen, certainly in an action movie.

So what makes The Last Jedi work, its core, is the triangle of dark history between Skywalker, Rei and Kylo Ren. I wish this had been more fleshed out with more flashbacks and twists; the mystery that hangs over Luke's broken relationship with Ren, and Rei's unknown parentage, could have been even more intriguing. Still, Rei's descent into the island pit, to confront her own darkness and doubts, is a Star Wars moment to savour. Driver, meanwhile, confirms in this latest performance that his is the most complex and mesmeric villain in sci-fi or fantasy since Heath Ledger's Joker.

There are, in fact, moments of beauty scattered throughout in the photography: none more so than Luke at the end as he faces that sunset of his youth, but also the shattering of a Star Destroyer in silent slow-mo, leaving the audience to enter some kind of heavenly dreamscape.

What's left to say that won't kill the mystery? My favourite character has gone the way of Han Solo and won't be there for the final act. What remains is a large and seemingly ever-expanding cast of barely memorable characters, and two super stars at war. In the meantime, and for Hamill's performance in particular, I will watch this film again.
The Party
 

Comments

No comments made yet. Be the first to submit a comment
Guest
Sunday, 21 January 2018

Captcha Image

What's On This Week

My Latest Posts

January 20, 2018

Naomi Klein: No Is Not Enough

in Books

Naomi Klein: No Is Not Enough I've been taking in books instead of movies, recently quite political ones, Christmas treats that I got for myself and am working through. Finally, I have something I want to write about. Naomi Klein's No Is Not Enough is the one book I'd recommend to anyone. It's a brilliant deconstruction of Trump and his P...
January 12, 2018

2018 All Shiny and New

2018 All Shiny and New 12.01.18 I wake up in darkness: too cold and too dark. It's 2018, Edinburgh-style, in a freezing bedroom. Thoughts of studies and part-time work come to me. In my part-time job I am writing a manual, with a page of FAQs relating to work. There's a question I kept to myself for obvious reasons, but it re-appears in the morning...
December 22, 2017

Final Message of 2017

Final Message of 2017 22.12.17 I wrote this post yesterday, but it had a strange effect on me afterwards: I wrote about my excitement buying things for my family, about spending money on stuff. Christmas can have a strange effect on people, on me at least. Briefly I got swept up in the glittering waves, imagining how it's going to be, tha...
December 16, 2017

Christmas Party

Christmas Party 16.12.17 Isn't mulled wine the best? I am still glowing with the aftertaste, from last night's Christmas party. I wore my new, shiny black pleated skirt – which you can see in the top photo if you really peer and use your imagination. Well done Gina. Must model New Favourite Skirt with better strategy next time. Anyway, some introdu...
December 15, 2017

Star Wars: The Last Jedi

Star Wars: The Last Jedi 15.12.17 I would watch this film again. Not for the lightsaber fights, which were strangely banal, or for the romance that develops between Boyega's Finn and Tan's Rose, which glowed slightly at the end. In fact not for the many shoulder-shrug participants of this movie: Oscar Isaac's ace pilot Po and his one-dimensional ch...
December 11, 2017

On Orange Is The New Black

On Orange Is The New Black 11.12.17 It was only a matter of time before I wrote about this show. Orange Is The New Black is the Netflix drama with one central location, where no one can escape, not the prison guards or their captors. There are several strong characters, all suffering from bad decisions that have cost them in life, from drug addicts...
What's On?
December 08, 2017

What's On?

December 08, 2017

What's On?

What's On? 08.12.17 Note: I wrote this for a What's On? post, but I'd like to add it here as a companion piece to the Christmas Party posting. I so seldom write about clothes, especially the ones I like, and writing this about beautiful skirts made me happy . . . This is a difficult What's On? to do, because I've been invited to two housewarming pa...
December 03, 2017

On AIDS, Twitter and a Bad Week at Work

On AIDS, Twitter, and a Bad Week at Work 03.12.17 I went to an event on AIDS on Friday afternoon. I know so little about AIDS, mainly fragments from my childhood in the 1980s, of adverts with gravestones, then later a televised concert commemorating the death of Freddie Mercury. In the late 1990s I read a book by journalist/broadcaster Andrew Neil,...
The Party
December 03, 2017

The Party

December 03, 2017

The Party

The Party 03.12.17 It finished so abruptly, there was hardly time for disappointment. The Party is a film that imagines what a soiree in London looks like. With the dialogue slightly dull, I stopped thinking about the minimal plot and wondered how much these characters would earn: Kristin Scott-Thomas's House of Commons Minister would have a salary...