Edinburgh Cinema

Edinburgh’s cinemas have their own, different feel. When I visit them, I’ll be writing about both the film and the place, giving you the organic experience. Film critics on the big scale can’t really cater for this, so I hope my reviews bring something extra in this respect.

The Death of Stalin


The Death of Stalin 21.10.17

My first issue wasn't with the film but the cinema. Two price hikes by Cameo within so many months left me with the cost of £9.20 for a film, on a student membership. It's strange how the little things can unsettle you beforehand, but the Cameo always felt like my cinema. Given that they've given a make-over to the bar, one which now provides fewer seats if you're single, I did sit down for the film in not the best of moods.

The Death of Stalin is a good, fun film regardless. Perhaps because it's playing for laughs, it doesn't evoke the potential for pathos: of once-idealistic men reduced to pall-bearers at the funeral of a monster. What we get is a power struggle between middle-aged administrators of varying degrees of competence. There is little talk of revolution or past ideals – when these politburo members decide to release a host of people, it seems to be as much down to self-interest as a fresh start. These are politicians exhausted by the regime of terror they've helped establish.

Which is also the biggest drawback with this film. Under the spotlight are politicians who remember the October 1917 revolution, when they tried to build a better world. Would it have been so difficult to incorporate just a bit more historical context, to give some added gravity? Because for me, something was ever so slightly missing, a comedy just a bit too lightweight for the subject. All the executions and arrests that go on in the background of this film didn't shake me in the way I think it should have. And the men themselves are the kind of self-interested careerists you'd imagine anywhere – with the possible exception of the brutal Beria.

Speaking of which: Beria, for me the most fascinating and complex member of Stalin's cabinet, is here just a flat-track, scheming bully. But historically, he was also a reformer, keen on allowing East Germany free elections, after Stalin's death, as if realizing the PR disaster the Iron Curtain was creating. Beria was so much more than just a sadistic torturer, even if he was that too. We don't see that side of him here, however. All we get is the scheming and the torture. The most memorable characters in this film are 2-D people whom we never really see behind the plotting.

So to my conclusion: The Death of Stalin isn't a film about ideologies or ideas, or an idealistic experiment gone wrong. It's one more exposé by Armando Ianucci, to go along with The Thick of It and Veep, about the venality and vanity of politicians. Yes there are several funny moments, mainly involving Jeremy Isaac's Marshal Zhukov, Michael Palin's Molotov and the pathetic Malenkov played by Jeffrey Tambor. I laughed, and enjoyed the light, anti-politician comedy. But weirdly for a comedy that should be so black, a curious lack of substance is what I took from this film. 
Thor: Ragnarok
Blade Runner 2049


No comments made yet. Be the first to submit a comment
Wednesday, 21 March 2018

Captcha Image

What's On This Week

My Latest Posts

March 19, 2018

Saturday Night Party at Valentina's

Saturday Night Party at Valentina's How is it possible to get lost on the way to Valentina's, of which I've been to twice before? Pulling behind me a suitcase filled with gifts and alcohol, I took a long route up my favourite street, then realized it wouldn't take me to the party. A swirling blizzard soon enveloped me, and I found myself at a motor...
March 18, 2018

Mary Magdalene

Mary Magdalene With mainstream films about Jesus, there's usually a fault line to contend with, between faith and secular interpretations: do you treat Jesus as a secular, historical figure, or the Son of God? Do you show the miracles as real? Or go for ambiguity, showing just enough for an open interpretation to satisfy different audiences? These ...
March 12, 2018

Red Sparrow

Red Sparrow This was not the film I was expecting, but the one I deserved. I had entered the screening room guessing at a female equivalent of James Bond, with its lead Jennifer Lawrence mixing fantasy and stupid violence. Instead, what I got for my assumptions was the channelling of John le Carre's brutalist Cold War vibe, of torture, double-cross...
March 11, 2018

Please, I don't want to dance

After the cinema yesterday evening, I entered a gay bar with some friends. I never go to gay bars – or any bars, except in cinemas. I get anxious in crowded rooms of strangers, where alcohol is flowing and the music is slightly deafening. Like Alicia Vikander's cyborg in Ex Machina , I feel vulnerable in my artificiality. In the gay bar we were oka...
March 04, 2018

Identity Politics

Identity Politics Sunday morning, I dropped £1 into the empty cardboard cup of a homeless person while the snow fell around us. It's the first time I've done such a thing in a while. It didn't make me feel good, it felt like a drop in the ocean. Earlier this week, the staff of my university went on strike. At one point, a picketing staff membe...
March 02, 2018

A Fantastic Woman

It's the most talked about trans movie since the problematic The Danish Girl  (2016), but A Fantastic Woman already has superior foundations through its casting and plot. Unlike Eddie Redmayne's depiction of Lili Elbe, the predicament of trans actress Daniela Vega's three-dimensional Marina does not involve a reason or fateful spark to ex...
The Square
February 28, 2018

The Square

February 28, 2018

The Square

The Square The trailer made this film fascinating; the two and a half hour cinema experience was a different, restless kettle of fish. The Square is an interesting if overly-long exploration of the managed edginess of a Copenhagen museum exhibition, and how its control – specifically the curator's control – pales to the weird fucked-upnes...
February 25, 2018


February 25, 2018


Anamorphosis On Thursday I went to a public speaking contest where I watched my flatmate get first prize. I was late, turning up in the dinner break, with everyone milling around me, chatting excitedly about talks I hadn't witnessed. I drifted wordlessly, in a gentle trauma where I couldn't articulate anything. I found a friend I hadn't talked to i...
Lady Bird
February 24, 2018

Lady Bird

February 24, 2018

Lady Bird

Lady Bird It covers the ground many trans women can't talk about, myself included, and I was reluctant to watch this film, and confront a past narrative that I'll sadly never share. Lady Bird is a coming-of-age movie in which Saoirse Ronan's Christine – aka self-styled Lady Bird – experiences the travails of her senior high school year, with boys a...