Edinburgh Cinema

Edinburgh’s cinemas have their own, different feel. When I visit them, I’ll be writing about both the film and the place, giving you the organic experience. Film critics on the big scale can’t really cater for this, so I hope my reviews bring something extra in this respect.

Thor: Ragnarok


Thor: Ragnarok 28.10.17

Two thirds of the way through Thor: Ragnarok, there's a superlative piece of slow-mo action that should have lasted longer. We see in a historical flashback the Valkyries – an all-woman army on winged horseback – approaching the story's villain, Cate Blanchett's Hela, in a final role of the dice. It's a scene akin to those of Lord of the Rings, when ancient battles held their decisive moments. Alas, this scene in Thor: Ragnarok goes no further, a plot hole forms – how did they defeat Hela the first time, when she seems to be invincible? – and a moment of fleeting beauty disappears.

The rest of Ragnarok is garish fun, with a strong middle section, and the occasional descents into nonsense. The opening half-hour is the worst, the film trying too hard to be cute and even parodying the superhero genre. A sequence of sharply-cut moments involving Dr Strange, in particular, is the cinematic equivalent of gibberish, and at a certain point left me feeling embarrassed, for a spoof that isn't funny.

What rescues Ragnarok is Thor's arrival on a junk-yard planet. Things settle, characters have time to talk, and action has its purpose. A strong cast in turn ping off each other – Hemsworth's Thor, Hiddleston's Loki and Thompson's Valkyrie are joined by Ruffalo's Hulk and their chemistry works; Goldblum is a wacky, amusing dictator, and a sub-plot with shades of Guardians of the Galaxy paints an engaging background, with monster-creatures wanting revolution.

It's worth noting that in this middle section, Thor has lost much of his power, and his hammer is gone; these are heroes a little less super than usual. It's a shame, indeed, that we have to leave this planet. Once back on Asgard, the pointlessness of a battle between invincible heroes resumes, with fight scenes that sometimes resemble computer-game simulation. Yet it's here that I should also state, in fairness, that the ending has been set up, and completes the arc of Thor and the truth of Valhalla – Hela does eventually get a poetic comeuppance. It's also the ending that makes sense, generically, and for the middle part, the film carves its own identity, a weird, cosmic fantasy. Perhaps this is how to utilize the talents of Cumberbatch's Dr Strange, as well as Thor and Hulk, heroes a little bit too super for Earthly battles: I'd like to see more of these kinds of Avengers films with the super powers reduced, and wacky, fantastic worlds and characters made more of, a marriage of Hell Boy and Pan's Labyrinth combined with these Marvel gods to give us something truly otherworldly.
Murder on the Orient Express
The Death of Stalin


No comments made yet. Be the first to submit a comment
Sunday, 22 May 2022

Captcha Image

By accepting you will be accessing a service provided by a third-party external to https://www.ginamaya.co.uk/