Transgender Life

I don’t want this site to be solely about being transgender. From my experiences so far, it’s not even something I could write about every week – being in the closet is far more intense and frustrating and writeable. However, there are moments when things happen, unique to trans people. I’d like to share those moments with you, and let you into the mystery.

Silenced by The Scotsman

The-Scotsman_Transphobia

On 11 June, The Scotsman published a deeply hostile article against transgender rights and activism in an opinion piece about the JK Rowling furore by its deputy political editor Gina Davidson. After much distress, I wrote a counter article which The Scotsman quietly ignored, after they had offered to pass it on to their Comment Editor. I experienced a similar series of events with The National, which published a similarly deeply hostile opinion-piece article about the JK Rowling furore filled with dog whistles against trans women, but which since has responded to my tailored counter article and offer to write an adapted article, with silence. This is the pattern I have experienced: the mainstream press will only publish articles that present trans women as a threat to cis women, and trans activism as abusive and irrational.


As a record of my experience with the Scottish media, here is my article to The Scotsman:


The Scotsman

Thursday 11 June 2020

Why abuse of JK Rowling is a problem for trans rights activists – Gina Davidson

JK Rowling is right that it is not hateful towards trans people to say that her life has been shaped by being female, says Gina Davidson


A response, by Gina Gwenffrewi

(Currently completing a PhD in Transgender Representations at the University of Edinburgh)


Amid the media furore two weeks ago surrounding an essay by JK Rowling that portrayed trans rights in opposition to the rights of natal women, it was galling to read Gina Davidson's opinion piece in The Scotsman that supported Rowling's position in so one-sided an account. Davidson's article starts, for example, by claiming that Rowling's only crime is 'to say that her life has been shaped by being female.' To be clear, Rowling's three-thousand-plus words, with its five main points and additional assertions, is far more complex and problematic. The world-famous novelist, for example, maintains in her essay her support for Maya Forstater, who lost her job after demanding the right to misgender trans people in the workplace. Such a right, the court rightly concluded in Forstater's legal defeat, would have set a precedent for making the work place 'an intimidating, hostile, degrading, humiliating or offensive environment' for trans people. Davidson's article omits to mention this distressing position maintained in Rowling's essay. More broadly, Rowling also claims a 'new trans activism' is 'pushing to erode the legal definition of sex and replace it with gender.' Yet this assertion is left unsubstantiated by Rowling, and fails to acknowledge how trans-inclusive legislation maintains the continued safeguards protecting women-only spaces such as prisons and refuges for victims of domestic-abuse – often the locations cited where trans rights are meant to infringe on the rights of natal women.

In its lack of reference to any scholarly research that details the actual benign implications of trans rights, and by its omission of some of the more controversial claims expressed by Rowling, Davidson's article has the unfortunate effect of contributing to the delegitimizing of trans people. This is consolidated by Davidson's tarring trans people with culpability for the more egregious examples online abuse suffered by Rowling. This conflation is then used to suggest rescinding trans rights that have peacefully been enjoyed by trans people for several decades. At one point, Davidson asks, 'Why would any woman agree to share private spaces such as changing rooms or toilets with the same people abusing Rowling?' Given the global phenomena of online trolling and abuse that characterizes so much social media, and which certainly includes the harassment of trans people as well as Rowling, Davidson's suggestion – however unrealistic it would be to police – of prohibiting trans women's access to women-only facilities such as public toilets, appears both excessive and unfair. Would Davidson argue it reasonable to remove the rights of other minorities, as a response to online abuse carried out by anonymous perpetrators in their name?

Distressingly, the skewed representation by Davidson conforms to a familiar and historic, dog-whistle association of trans women with violence and misogyny. Such associations characterize, for example, the delegitimizing strategies by anti-transgender scholars such Janice Raymond and Sheila Jeffreys over several decades. The innuendo on Davidson's part is especially evident in her reference to the Gender Recognition Act, whose equivalence has been peacefully established in several countries, from Argentina to the Republic of Ireland. Davidson claims in relation to it 'a veiled seal of approval to out-and-out misogyny; a nod and wink to the men who've never liked the idea of equality in the first place, to let loose with their abuse; men from both the right and the left of politics.'

Who are these misogynists and men from both right and left of politics whom Davidson infers as supporting such trans-inclusive legislation? A veritable roll-call of influential, commentators hostile to various trans rights and activism across the political spectrum in fact suggests the opposite, including Slavoj Žižek, Nick Cohen, Rod Liddle, Jordan Peterson, Jeremy Clarkson, Jonathan Ross, Ben Shapiro, Milo Yiannopoulos, Douglas Murray and Graham Linehan, the latter recently having had his twitter account suspended for his online harassment of transgender people. Such specific abuse, and the broader attacks by high-profile male journalists against trans rights and/or trans identity, unfortunately, appears not to fit the narrative.

What is most distressing about Davidson's article is its presentation of a threatening trans activism at a time when trans rights are being challenged or removed in Europe and the U.S.A. The Trump/Pence administration has attempted several legislations to remove trans rights since coming into office, while in Hungary, trans identity has effectively been prohibited since May 2020. The kind of trans-exclusionary access rights suggested by Davidson are also currently being discussed publicly by Liz Truss of the UK government. The pattern, overwhelmingly, is of a marginalized minority whose rights in several countries led by populist administrations are in retreat. To see The Scotsman encourage this development in Scotland is, for trans people at least, deeply troubling.

Sterile like the moon: the joys of transgender hea...
 

Comments

No comments made yet. Be the first to submit a comment
Guest
Thursday, 06 August 2020

Captcha Image

What's On This Week

My Latest Posts

July 01, 2020

Silenced by The Scotsman

​ On 11 June, The Scotsman published a deeply hostile article against transgender rights and activism in an opinion piece about the JK Rowling furore by its deputy political editor Gina Davidson. After much distress, I wrote a counter article which The Scotsman quietly ignored, after they had offered to pass it on to their Comment Editor. I experie...
May 11, 2020

The Book of Queer Prophets, curated by Ruth Hunt

in Books

  The Book of Queer Prophets: 24 Writers on Sexuality and Religion The historically fraught relationship between Abrahamic religions and LGBT+ identities provides the backdrop to The Book of Queer Prophets , a collection of twenty-four meditations by public figures who identify as both religious and LGBT+. The book's curator, the for...
May 09, 2020

Queer/Transgender short film: Mesmeralda

Joshua Matteo's short film, Mesmeralda , merging horror with esoterica, is now out on youtube . As with his previous work Metanoia , we see youthful trans actors racing through the empty streets of a moonlit New York, haunted by symbols and stalked by a masked figure of violent intentions. Mesmeralda , as described by Matteo, is the companion ...
March 08, 2020

Sterile like the moon: the joys of transgender healthcare

Sterile like the moon: the joys of transgender healthcare Summer, 2016: Gina's Big Bang, as transitioning begins A bureaucratic question in a sun-lit room. My medical practitioner asks me if I intend to have children. The question lingers, but the self-loathing is instant. No, I won't be having children. The practitioner nods. She moves on to the n...
November 10, 2019

General Election

General Election 12 December 2019 I spent the last election in an office, alone but for the company of a colleague. We watched the BBC's coverage while I drank wine, downbeat and expecting austerity and the absence of hope to triumph. Then we saw the exit poll and hung around, disbelieving at the sight of the kindled embers and lukewarm glow of a f...
Joker
October 05, 2019

Joker

October 05, 2019

Joker

Joker The trailer did its work, flashing images of anomie and fury perfectly pitched for these unstable times of precarious working conditions, grievance and institutional indifference. For these same reasons, Joker , directed by Todd Phillips and starring Joaquin Phoenix as the protagonist, has attracted pre-release criticisms like few other recen...
September 29, 2019

Resisting Whiteness event 2019

Resisting Whiteness one-day event, Edinburgh Returning for the second consecutive year, Resisting Whiteness came yesterday to the Pleasance Theatre in Edinburgh, providing an intense and inspiring series of panels, as well as a wonderful spoken word section, and a final segment based around the documentary short Invisible by internationally-acclaim...
August 21, 2019

Hearty by Emma Frankland

Hearty by Emma Frankland Raw and dripping with punk aesthetic, this one-woman-show's one-woman emerges in ripped tights and a T-shirt that paraphrases loudly the words of anti-trans theorist Germaine Greer: Lop Your Dick Off. My first impression of Emma Frankland is edgily uncertain and in awe, her Lady-Gaga-looks combined with Heath Ledger's mesme...
August 21, 2019

Pronoun, Pass, & Amnesty International

Transgender drama: Pronoun To be clear at the outset, this was the production of a youth theatre group, not a highly resourced team of experienced, professional career actors – although some of the performances left a powerful impression, and the show as a whole achieved some remarkable moments. Pronoun , written by Evan Placey, follows the transit...